OVERVIEW
This is my first book by Sarah Penner. It had an intriguing premise with a dual timeline of Italian sea witches (streghe de mare) in 1821 and a contemporary nautical archaeologist in Positano, Italy.
You had me at witches! Italian witches! Italian sea witches!
Unfortunately, I liked this book, but I didn't love it.
OVERALL REVIEW: 4.0 stars
Writing: 4.0 stars
The writing is good, descriptive, and uneven at times.
I felt like the 1821 timeline could have been elevated with more authentic language to the time and region by including more Italian phrases and dialogue. It felt too contemporary for me.
Character development: 4.0 stars
The main characters are Mari (sea witch - 1821) and Haven (archaeologist - contemporary time).
The secondary characters are Holmes (a good-hearted sailor), Matteo and Massimo (evil shipowners), and the other sea witches in Positano during the 1821 time frame.
The tertiary characters Enzo (Haven's dive friend), Mal (Haven's good friend), and Savina (Enzo's eccentric mother) are in the contemporary time.
There were just so many characters that were integral to the plot, yet they weren't developed enough. The most developed (and interesting) characters were Mari and Holmes, and they were great!
Storyline: 4.0 stars
The 1821 storyline is Mari and the other witches protecting Positano from pirates, thus the "Almafi Curse". Mari was a fascinating character who could have had the entire book about her.
The contemporary time is about Haven, who is researching and diving to determine how shipwrecks stack upon themselves. This work, along with Haven's character being a bit boring, didn't resonate with me.
The location was the Amalfi Coast, primarily in Positano, Italy.
Memorable/Informative: 3.5 stars
I had heard the term strega (witch in Italian), but streghe de mare (sea witches in Italian) and stregheria (archaic for witchcraft in Italian) were completely new terms for me. I loved learning a bit of Italian as a bonus.
Book cover: 5.0 stars
Gorgeous.
Book title: 4.0 stars
I'm torn on it!
Definite recommend
Los Angeles Public Library (LAPL) borrow: ebook
The Amalfi Curse by Sarah Penner
333 pages
Park Row
Release date: 4/29/2025
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
Los Angeles Public Library (LAPL)
TRIGGER WARNINGS:
Sexual assault, kidnapping, murder, witchcraft, gun violence, death, death of a parent, grief, medical content, blood, pregnancy, and moderate cursing.
Happy reading,
Dorothea 💜