Happy reading,
Dorothea 💜
Reviews of physical books, ebooks, and audiobooks personally read or listened to by me! booksbydorothea - Instagram; booksbydorothea - Threads; Books by Dorothea - Goodreads
The Third Gilmore Girl by Kelly Bishop (audiobook)
OVERVIEW
Writing: 5.0 stars
Kelly is a great writer and was so real and honest. She wrote about her turbulent childhood with an abusive father, but a wonderful mother. Kelly also writes about her mistakes, triumphs, and dreams without sugar-coating them!
Narration: 5.0 stars
Kelly has that gorgeous, gravelly voice that I have always wanted. She could read anything for me and I would love it.
Character Arc: 5.0 stars
The audiobook is mostly told chronologically which is what I prefer in memoirs.
Memorable: 5.0 stars
I knew Kelly was incredibly talented, but I had no idea about her Emmy winner for "A Chorus Line". I have seen it several times in local theater because I love it! Kelly explains how "A Chorus Line" came about which is a fascinating story!
The best part for me is that Kelly always stayed true to Kelly. She spoke up for what was right and advocated for herself in the male-centric theater eras and in Hollywood.
Entertaining: 5.0 stars
Kelly was funny, open, and just a great storyteller. She is the type of individual you could talk to for hours and not realize how much time had passed.
Book cover: 5.0 stars
So pretty.
Book title: 5.0 stars
Perfect!
HIGHLY recommend
STATISTICS
Release date of 9/17/2024
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
Happy reading,
Dorothea 💜
When We Flew Away by Alice Hoffman (ebook)
I have no words. This book gutted me. But, I must review it and highly recommend it as it is an amazing historical novel.
I read The Diary of Anne Frank sometime in junior high which is the target audience for this novel. It is a powerful, thought-provoking, and intense read about the time before Anne started her diary in 1942 while in hiding with her family. Reading this historical novel and Anne's diary will help our young people stop events like the Holocaust from happening again.
The premise of this book is purely fiction; although, Alice Hoffman has done extensive research into the Frank family to write this beautiful book.
I hope this amazing novel helps us learn from history, but I am terrified that we haven't learned enough. Anne's motto at the end of the book, "remember me" is so moving and our marching orders for today and the future.
NOTE: This is a historical novel written for middle schoolers. It is not the same as Alice Hoffman's other historical novels. The writing is for a middle-school audience, but is still written amazingly well. Please do not read or denigrate this book because of its target audience.
Writing: 5.0 stars
Alice Hoffman is my absolute favorite author. Her writing style is just so lovely and thought-provoking. The specific details of the horrors by the Germans in the Netherlands, against most specifically the Jews, are appropriate for the targeted age group. This novel was not watered-down for the age group as it was real, raw, and terrifying. I hope Alice's beautiful writing creates intense discussions about what happened in Europe during WWII and how to avoid it from happening again.
Character development: 5.0 stars
The main character is Anne Frank, period.
The secondary characters are Anne's family, Otto Frank (father), Edith Frank (mother), Margot Frank (older sister), and Oma (grandmother).
The tertiary characters are the people living in Amsterdam, the Frank family helpers, the German army, and the Dutch police.
Storyline: 5.0 stars
The storyline broke my heart. The Franks left Germany around Kristallnacht and emigrated to the Netherlands feeling that they would be safe there. They were wrong. Once they realized what was happening there, it was too late to emigrate to England, Switzerland, or the US. They were horribly struck with no real options or no way out other than to go into hiding when Margot was called up for one of the "labor camps".
The main location was Amsterdam and the environs.
Memorable/Informative: 5.0 stars
Since the Netherlands was considered the most welcoming and progressive country in Europe, it was a natural place for the Jews to flee. However, it was heartbreaking to read about how many of the non-Jewish Dutch became indoctrinated in the cult of Hitler and were cruel and hurtful to the Jewish people.
Additionally, approximately 75% of the Dutch Jewish population was murdered by Hilter. This is the largest percentage of any Western country.
Finally, there are many similarities between what is happening in our country now and what happened in Germany, but to a lesser degree. The parallels are terrifying as Trump admires Hitler. We have a recourse that the German people didn't - we can vote.
Book cover: 5.0 stars
Appropriate. Look for the symbolism on the cover!
Book title: 5.0 stars
Perfection.
HIGHEST recommendation
BOOK INFORMATION
Los Angeles Public Library (LAPL) borrow (ebook)
When We Flew Away by Alice Hoffman
196 pages
Scholastic Press
Release date of 9/17/2024
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
Happy reading,
Dorothea 💜
Writing: 5.0 stars
Ina writes beautifully. That is no surprise as she used to work for Presidents Ford and Carter!
I love how she talks about food, friendship, and life with it all being interconnected. It was lovely.
Narration: 5.0 stars
Great narration. Ina is not a perfect speaker or an on-camera personality which she readily admits in the audiobook. But that nervousness and imperfection make her so approachable and so likable. She is real!
She is funny, a swear word dropper, and a straight-shooter - my kind of gal!
Character Arc: 5.0 stars
The audiobook is told chronologically which I thoroughly enjoyed.
Memorable: 5.0 stars
She spills her guts, so to speak, about her life and how she rose above a harsh family life in an affluent part of Connecticut. Something that her father said to her resonates with me deeply and sadly.
Ina found her love, Jeffrey, very early in life. But, she also knew what she needed in her marriage which she asked for and received.
I was shocked at what happened when Ina and Jeffrey applied for a mortgage in the early 1970s. The loan officer wouldn't consider her income because "she would get pregnant and stay home". Geez, how sexist and misogynist!
Entertaining: 5.0 stars
Ina was so funny. She has a great sense of humor and would be a hoot to have a meal with.
Book cover: 5.0 stars
So pretty.
Book title: 5.0 stars
Words to live by.
HIGHLY recommend
STATISTICS
Release date of 10/1/2024
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
Happy reading,
Dorothea 💜
This is the fourth book in a five-book series. I would describe the series, Her Majesty the Queen Investigates, as a "cozy mystery series. I say "cozy" because the book isn't horribly graphic. I also love the idea of Queen Elizabeth II solving crimes - it just tracks for me.
The premise of this book is a double murder in Chelsea with potential involvement with aristocrats and royals. The time frame is in 1957, a departure from the rest of the series. In this book, the Queen begins her working relationship with Joan McCraw, acting APS (Assistant Personal Secretary).
This book takes place primarily near multiple royal residences in England and Scotland.
I hope the fifth and next book isn't the last (say it isn't so, S.J. Bennett)!!!
Writing: 4.0 stars
The writing is good. It is not overly descriptive but rather a crisp, no-nonsense style like how the Queen comes across.
I loved that the Queen's clothing and jewels were described in detail. She was still young and coming into her personal power as a monarch and woman.
Character development: 4.0 stars
The character development of the two main characters of Queen Elizabeth II and Joan, her Assistant Personal Secretary (APS) is in its infancy. But, the Queen trusted herself and found someone she could trust in Joan. Both are strong women which I always love reading about.
The secondary characters are the Queen's extended family, local nobility, acquaintances, and her secretaries.
The tertiary characters are the police investigators, victims, and witnesses.
Storyline: 4.5 stars
The storyline was a good whodunit. The twists and turns made this mystery so much fun. Of course, I had no clue who the killer or killers were.
The main locations were the many royal residences and surrounding areas in Great Britain.
Memorable/Informative: 4.0 stars
I am a huge Anglophile as many of my ancestors immigrated from that area.
I was shocked that Joan was perceived by many of the male aristocrats and the Queen's male secretaries as disreputable because she was Irish. This was 1957!
Book cover: 4.0 stars
Nice.
Book title: 4.5 stars
On point.
Suggestion:
An explanation of the titles and how to correctly address the nobility and royalty would be helpful for this clueless American reader!
DEFINITE recommend
BOOK INFORMATION
NetGalley ARC (ebook)
A Death in Diamond (Her Majesty The Queen Investigates #4) by S.J. Bennett
407 pages
Zaffre
Release date of 1/21/2025
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
Happy reading,
Dorothea 💜
Writing: 3.0 stars
Unfortunately, this book is not well written.
It is based on tapes Lisa Marie recorded to begin the foundation of her autobiography. Riley Keough, her daughter, fills in some of the gaps in the audio to make it more understandable and add a back story.
I am surprised that it is an Oprah's Book Club pick.
Narration: 3.5 stars
This book has three narrators. First is Lisa Marie whose poorly recorded excerpts are included and are the most powerful and raw part of this audiobook. Second is Riley who read well but was emotionally flat (as I think she is still processing so much). Finally, Julia Roberts does an outstanding job for most of the audiobook.
Due to the three narrators, an audiobook is the way to go with this memoir, IMHO.
Character Arc: 3.0 stars
The audiobook is told chronologically which I thoroughly enjoyed.
My real issue is that this book is just too short due to huge time gaps in Lisa Marie's story. Her life was not fully explored which is disappointing.
Memorable: 3.0 stars
Yes, there are some salacious parts, but most don't add depth to the story. It is all personal decisions and I support Lisa Maria in them all.
The biggest takeaway for me is what would Lisa Marie's life have been IF her father hadn't died on that fateful day. Good, better, or worse - we will never know. This book is all about grief and loss along with generational trauma including drug and alcohol abuse.
Entertaining: 3.0 stars
It wasn't entertaining per se. It was just what it was.
Book cover: 3.0 stars
A much better picture could have been picked.
Book title: 3.0 stars
Unsure if it is a good title.
LUKEWARM recommend
STATISTICS
Release date of 10/8/2024
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
Lisa Marie Presley/Riley Keough
Happy reading,
Dorothea 💜
OVERVIEW
This is the fifth book written by three author friends (Williams, Willig, and White) AKA The Three W's. The only author of the three I have read is Beatriz Williams which is how I found this book. This is my first novel by the three authors in collaboration.
I know this book was satire and tongue-in-cheek, but I liked the book rather than loved it.
Writing: 4.5 stars
The writing is good. I could not determine who wrote what chapters so it is a well-done collaboration.
I liked that the three main characters had their own chapters and at the beginning of the novel each started with a police interrogation. The interrogations were hysterically funny!
Character development: 4.0 stars
The main characters were Kat, Emma, and Cassie. They are three diverse writers who meet to write a book together at a Scottish castle. The three main characters were as different as their individual genres.
The secondary characters are Detective Chief Inspector (DCI) McIntosh (the police officer investigating a murder), Calum (castle caretaker), Morag (castle housekeeper), and Archie (estate manager).
The tertiary characters are the murdered individual, townspeople, and other characters that move the story along.
Storyline: 3.0 stars
The storyline is told in flashbacks with police interrogations and then the chapter focuses on one of the three main characters. This was the best part of the book.
The book was long and could have been edited more. This novel is slow for the first 75% of the book other than the police interrogations. Then it takes off for the last 25% and is fast-moving and fun. So for me, the chapters with the police interrogations could have been very edited.
The main location was Inner Hebrides, Scotland.
Memorable/Informative: 3.5 stars
I enjoyed learning a small amount about the Inner Hebrides and how each island community is connected.
Book cover: 4.0 stars
Okay.
Book title: 4.0 stars
Meh.
DEFINITE recommend
BOOK INFORMATION
NetGalley ARC (ebook)
The Author's Guide to Murder by Beatriz Williams, Lauren Willig, and Karen White
416 pages
William Morrow
Release date of 11/5/2024
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
Happy reading,
Dorothea 💜