booksbydorothea
My reviews of physical books, eBOOKS, audioBOOKS, and ARCs were personally read by me! booksbydorothea - Instagram; booksbydorothea - Bluesky booksbydorothea - StoryGraph; BOOKSBYDOROTHEA - Goodreads
Featured Post
Tuesday, March 25, 2025
REVIEW - Sunrise on the Reaping (audioBOOK)
OVERVIEW
Wow! This audiobook was not what I was expecting at all! Listen to this as an audioBOOK - it is exceptional!
This is the fifth book and the second prequel in The Hunger Games series. It is my favorite of the entire series because I liked the character Haymitch Abernathy more than Katniss Everdeen. Heresy, I know!
This book answered many questions in the series and fit in as the fifth book like a puzzle piece. Hopefully, Suzanne Collins will end the series with this book. It ended well and doesn't need more. IMNSHO!
OVERALL REVIEW: 4.0 stars
Writing: 4.0 stars
The writing was perfect for a young adult novel. No, it is not Shakespeare, nor should it be. Young adult books are for young adults and to encourage the love of reading, but there is some Edgar Allen Poe sprinkled.
This is not a book with a perfect main character - it is told from a 16-year-old's perspective. It hit the young adult's mindset and thought process well by writing TO young adults.
Narration: 5.0 stars
Jefferson White (Yellowstone and Chicago P.D. actor) was the perfect choice for the narration. He captured the nuances, emotions, and thoughts of a teenage boy stuck in a horrible and untenable situation.
Character Arc: 4.0 stars
The audiobook is chronological and aligns perfectly as it is book #0.5 (second prequel). We already "know" what happens to Haymitch, but we get the backstory.
The book opens in District 12 on Haymitch Abernathy's 16th birthday and reaping day for the 50th Hunger Games and the second quarter quell. Each district must provide two boys and two girls as tributes.
The Hunger Games itself has evolved from book #0 with more pomp and circumstance, but not yet to the level of book #1. There are many characters including some from book #0 and characters that appear in book #1.
This book is primarily from Haymitch's perspective and includes his thoughts, feelings, and fears. Perfectly age-appropriate musings including his interactions with the other District 12 tributes, the tribute group, and "the powers that be" in the Capital.
Memorable: 3.5 stars
Honestly, I didn't find it exceedingly memorable. But it was violent and horrific at times. However, there is little cursing and no sex. Oddly, violence is okay for young adult novels, but not sex or cursing.
Entertaining: 3.5 stars
Morbidly and violently, this book is entertaining. But, it is not a series or book I would want to read again - once was enough.
Book cover: 4.5 stars
Aligned with the series.
Book title: 5.0 stars
Excellent choice.
DEFINITE recommend
STATISTICS
Los Angeles Public Library (LAPL) borrow: audioBOOK
Sunrise on the Reaping (The Hunger Games, #0.5) by Suzanne Collins
Scholastic Audiobooks
12 hours, 48 minutes
Release date of 3/18/2025
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
TRIGGER WARNINGS
Death, death of child, violence, blood, gore, medical content, classicism, war
Happy reading,
Dorothea ๐
Monday, March 24, 2025
Sunday, March 23, 2025
REVIEW - A Woman of Firsts (physical book)
OVERVIEW
This biography shares the extraordinary and groundbreaking story of Margaret (AKA Peggy, Peg) O'Shaughnessy Heckler. I am sorry I knew absolutely nothing about her at all before reading this biography. She is the type of leader that we really need today - who leads by example, crosses party lines, and uses diplomacy and reasoning to get things done! My kind of "girls girl"!
Another "girls girl" I want to thank is my dear friend, Valerie. Thank you so much for sharing Margaret by sending me an author-signed copy. I love you, sweet friend!
OVERALL REVIEW: 4.0 stars
Writing: 3.5 stars
This book was written by Margaret's daughter-in-law, Kimberly, who also had help from professional writers. The writing is strong and well-done with a detailed footnote section and an index. This was a ten-year labor of love.
I enjoyed the book, but it was more like a history book than a biography. It was dry, at times, and lacked the anecdotes and stories that make a biography sing. It needed more like the story about eating pond fish in China, oh, MY!
This is a dense and political read, but it is so well-researched. Margaret was one hell of a leader! I really liked this book, but I didn't love it. I wanted so much more!
Character development: 5.0 stars
There are no characters per se as it is a biography told chronologically (my favorite). But, the main focus is Margaret who had a very unusual childhood. Her parents were Irish immigrants and her father did not want children. Her mother, unexpectedly, became pregnant. So her parents paid someone to care for and raise Margaret. But, inexplicably they visited her once a month. At one point, her parents traveled to Ireland to leave her with relatives when Margaret was about six. Thankfully, providence intervened and they all returned to the United States.
Margaret quickly discovered that education was the key to her future. She did so well in school that she received many scholarships to private schools including law school. Margaret was one of the first women to graduate from Boston College Law School.
When she had difficulty finding a job as an attorney. So she worked for law school friends and was on the Massachusetts Governor's Council which was the start of her political career.
Margaret was a Republican congresswoman from a blue district in the blue state of Massachusetts. She was elected on her own merit and not appointed after the death of her husband. Margaret was instrumental in the passing of the ECOA (Equal Credit Opportunity Act) and the ERA (Equal Rights Amendment) in Congress.
Also, she was the Secretary of HHS (Health and Human Services) during Ronald Reagan's second term. She did much to fight the AIDS epidemic, minority medical care inequalities, and Medicare-covered hospice.
Finally, she was the first female American Ambassador to Ireland.
Storyline: 4.0 stars
The storyline starts when her parents emigrate to the United States and ends with Margaret's death. The time after Margaret was Ambassador to Ireland and returned to the United States until her death was very rushed and not covered fully.
Additionally, Margaret basically single-parented her children as her husband stayed behind in Wellesley, Massachusetts and she and the children resided in McClean, Virginia. I know she had help, but HOW did she do it all???
Also, since Margaret was not a trained manager or diplomat, how did she handle running HHS or being Ambassador to Ireland? What was her secret sauce?
The locations were Massachusetts, Virginia, Washington D.C., and Ireland.
Memorable/Informative: 4.0 stars
Margaret did so much during the beginning of the AIDS epidemic when the Reagan Administration was silent and did nothing. So many lives were saved by her policies and budget requests while she was at HHS. Unfortunately, many including myself did not know what she did. Thank you, Margaret, for your kind and caring heart!
Book cover: 3.5 stars
Meh! There had to be a better picture of Margaret with President Reagan!
Book title: 4.0 stars
Somewhat accurate.
STRONG recommend
Physical book gift
Isola by Allegra Goodman
368 pages
Lyons Press
Release date: 2/18/2025
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
TRIGGER WARNING: Abandonment, sexism, inappropriate physical contact and behavior, pregnancy, divorce, alcoholism, car accident
Happy reading,
Dorothea ๐
Saturday, March 22, 2025
My next ebook is...
DNF - The Wedding People (eBOOK)
Wednesday, March 19, 2025
My next audioBOOK is...
REVIEW - A Kid from Marlboro Road (audioBOOK)
OVERVIEW
This audiobook is a work of fiction but loosely based on Edward Burns's life growing up in Long Island, New York. It is about the summer that the narrator, Kneenie, turns from twelve to thirteen during the 1970s in his Irish-American and Italian-American, Roman Catholic community.
This is the first book of three. So there will be more about Kneenie and it will interesting to learn what specific time in Kneenie's life is next!
OVERALL REVIEW: 4.5 stars
Writing: 4.5 stars
The writing was perfect for an audiobook, but I am unsure if it would translate well as a written book. Plus, Edward beautifully captures the writing of an almost thirteen-year-old boy in the 1970s which could be off-putting to some readers.
This is not supposed to be a perfect book with a perfect writer - it is told from a kid's perspective. That is why I really enjoyed this book! The perspective was fun and fresh!
Narration: 5.0 stars
The narration was by Edward and perfect! He captured all the nuances, emotions, and feelings of a boy becoming a teenager! Plus, he has Irish accents down pat!
Character Arc: 4.5 stars
The audiobook is chronological with explanatory asides for things readers may not know about. I loved the asides!
The book opens with the wake of his beloved Pop (grandfather) and ends the day before the start of school. It is a lovely arc telling all of the wild and crazy as well as bittersweet and beautiful events that happened that summer.
There are a lot of characters including Kneenie's parents, brother, relatives, neighbors, classmates, and even a maple tree!
It was a short audiobook at 4 hours and 45 minutes, so more detail or additional stories would have been nice. I would have enjoyed more about the immediate family dynamic and Kneenie!
Memorable: 4.5 stars
Kneenie's family was similar to many in the 1970s, especially in the suburbs. The mothers felt stuck at housekeeping and if they worked, they had two jobs! Something that hasn't changed in fifty years. The fathers didn't understand their wives and didn't really try to do so. It was a vicious circle and still is!
The stories about Kneenie's extended family are fascinating! I loved the stories the elders told although they may be true or may not be. But these stories have been told so many times they are officially family lore!
Entertaining: 5.0 stars
The story about the poem, the maple tree, and Jesus is hysterical and the best of the book! Although, many of the stories in the book are also very funny or poignant!
Book cover: 5.0 stars
Perfect.
Book title: 5.0 stars
Excellent choice.
STRONG recommend
STATISTICS
Los Angeles Public Library (LAPL) borrow: audioBOOK
A Kid from Marlboro Road by Edward Burns
Blackstone Publishing
4 hours, 45 minutes
Release date of 9/10/2024
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
TRIGGER WARNINGS
"Potty humor", death, cursing, medical content, blood
Happy reading,
Dorothea ๐
Tuesday, March 18, 2025
REVIEW - Isola (eBOOK)
OVERVIEW
What a story and what a book! This historical novel is based on the life of Marguerite de La Rocque de Roberval, a French noblewoman.
This novel kept showing up on reading lists and I dismissed it as another popular, fluffy book. I. WAS. SO. WRONG!
Alegra has written six previous novels and I look forward to reading them and anything else she chooses to write!
OVERALL REVIEW: 5.0 stars
Writing: 5.0 stars
Allegra made this unbelievable story come to life. The descriptions were beautifully detailed from the gory parts to the mundane tasks necessary to fully tell the story. The descriptions of the time on the uninhabited island in the Gulf of Saint Lawrence during all seasons were sheer poetry and so gorgeous.
This is a dense and intense read, but it is so well-researched and fascinating!
Character development: 5.0 stars
The main character is Marguerite, an orphaned woman of noble blood who was marooned as an adult on an inhospitable and uninhabited island in the Gulf of Saint Lawrence.
The secondary characters are Roberval (Marguerite's guardian), Auguste (Roberval's secretary and Marguerite's friend), and Damienne (Marguerite's servant).
The tertiary characters are Claire (Marguerite's friend) and Madame D'Artois (Claire's mother and Marguerite's friend). The island that Marguerite was abandoned on is also a character unto itself.
Many characters, including ones in France, New France (Canada), and the shipboard journeys on the Atlantic Ocean, add depth to the story.
Storyline: 5.0 stars
Six sections in this book make up the novel: Pรฉrigord, La Rochelle, At Sea, The Isle, The Isle, and At Sea, La Rochelle, Pรฉrigord. This historical fiction novel covers 1531-1544 in France, New France, and at sea on the Atlantic Ocean. That may be a short period of only thirteen years, but so much happens to the characters.
The story is of Marguerite who is orphaned and whose wealth and control are given to her social-climbing cousin Roberval. He uses her estate for his enrichment and power. Eventually, Roberval takes Marguerite on an ocean voyage to New France. She is left on an island until her rescue and return to France.
The locations were Pรฉrigord and La Rochelle, France; time at sea; and an island in New France.
Memorable/Informative: 5.0 stars
I never knew how early France sent explorers like Cartier and Roberval to find the non-existent northwest passage. Also, I was unaware of the difficulty and violence between the French settlers and the Native peoples in Quebec. Ultimately, the French founded Quebec about the same time the English founded Jamestown with similar difficulties for both settlements.
Also, in 16th century France, a French woman's rights and estate were lost when her parents or husband died then either her husband, close male relative, or son inherited instead of the woman. The subjugation of women was terrifying, horrifying, and demeaning. Sadly, some of this still persists today.
Book cover: 5.0 stars
Beautiful!
Book title: 5.0 stars
On point!
HIGHLY recommend
Los Angeles County Library (LAC) borrow: eBOOK
Isola by Allegra Goodman
368 pages
The Dial Press
Release date: 2/5/2025
INFORMATIONAL LINKS
TRIGGER WARNING: Violence, torture, death of a parent, death of a child, sexual situations, gore, abandonment, execution
Happy reading,
Dorothea ๐